Critical Thinking & CALL

Today I reviewed websites promoting the Critical Thinking skills building programs Rationale and Inspirations. My reaction in one word -- Borrrrring! Both programs have their uses, but I was bored almost to the point of profanity by both of these sites. The Rationale video is a huge snooze fest. And the thought of using either of these programs with students dulls my dreary brain. I much prefer to teach critical thinking skills with hands-on, interactive, face-to-face activities that challenge students to think creatively. I can imagine using sites like these if there is absolutely no other alternative or for limited use as tools in an otherwise dynamic classroom. I could imagine using these programs to help more advanced students construct complex arguments, etc. Both programs could be useful for teaching students how to organize their thoughts for writing essays, arguments and other scholarly papers. If they were used as part of a group project learning experience, they would be more interactive. However, kinesthetic learners of all ages will be crying on the inside. I was especially sad to see that the Inspirations program teaches math skills with computerized versions of manipulatives. Boo hoo. I do not think these products are necessary in the average classroom. I don't think the potential for improved learning is very high. Powerpoint has most of the same capabilities. I am definitely not sold.